Over the years, I have written a little about one of the most important decisions in church history that few people know of. I am writing about, of course – Pelagius vs. Augustine! (Ta da!) Bigger than Mothra vs. Godzilla – Foreman vs. Ali – Coke vs. Pepsi. The fact that almost everyone knows about Augustine tells us who won, but I think the wrong choice was made. It isn’t that Augustine wasn’t an amazing theologian – that cannot be disputed. His writing set the stage for Christian theology for the next 1600 years, so I in no way would denigrate his value to the church’s traditions. The controversy, in a nutshell, is that while Augustine created the concept of original sin, Pelagius believed in original blessings. Pelagius believed that we are basically good; Augustine believed that we are basically sinful. Without original sin, the need for Jesus could come into question, something I will not defend. However…
Original Sin posits that humanity was created as deeply flawed, and this is caused by Adam and Eve’s disobedience of God in the Garden of Eden. The only rule God had was to not eat the fruit of the knowledge of good and evil – that’s it. The perfect life they had was ruined because they listened to the Serpent’s advice. The Serpent, however, told the truth – if they ate it, God said, they would die. They didn’t. Some interpreters believe this meant that God intended for human beings to live forever, but the Bible never says that. Others believe it meant spiritual death. That isn’t there either. Of course, the wayward couple is punished with hard work and pain in childbirth – along with other stuff – and they are kicked out of the Garden. A big armed angel is placed as a guard so they can’t sneak back in.
I rejected original sin decades ago. I find the entire story to be a bit much; the idea that God would condemn all of humanity to eternal punishment over this transgression seems petty to me. In the entire creation story in Genesis 1, each day ends with God stating that it is Good – one day, it’s Very Good! At no point does Scripture say that God has created any part of the universe to be bad or evil. I am with Pelagius – I think we are created with Original Goodness, but with one catch. Free Will. Free Will messes the whole thing up – it gives us the choice to find our own way and make our own mistakes. Free Will is God’s way of saying, “I made you to be good – will you take Me up on it?” Free Will rejects the many excuses that have been made over the eons about the nature of God; it says that God made us, now we have to live it. Are you and I Good Witches, or are we Bad? We are free to choose, so choose wisely.
Prayer – Holy God, thank You for making us in Your image, good at the core with the freedom to choose. May we choose wisely. Amen.
Today’s art is “Free Will” by Stephen Sawyer.