In Steven Pearlstein’s book, “Moral Capitalism: Why Fairness Won’t Make Us Poor”, the author attempts to bring us back to Adam Smith’s concepts of how all people can thrive when competition and the marketplace are done well. Pearlstein writes, “We’re missing a key tenet of Adam Smith’s wealth of nations: without trust and social capital, democratic capitalism cannot survive. Further, equality of incomes and opportunity need not come at the expense of economic growth.” It is clear to me that economic systems are neither moral nor immoral in the same way money isn’t evil. The love of money or wealth or greed or power is at the root of all kinds of evil, Scripture tells us. When we turn a thing into the most important part of our world, we fall into idol worship. When money matters more than people, we are all screwed.
We have seen a slight shift recently towards socialism, especially among those under 35. This shift is credited with the election of a few politicians who call themselves “democratic socialists.” There’s been a lot of finger-pointing and handwringing over this, and it might be something to be concerned about. Or it might be a warning that capitalism has become a perversion of itself – an out-of-control monster that no longer serves us well. The “greed is good” movement of the 1990’s shows us that, in fact, greed is not good, and that the growing number of billionaires and – soon – trillionaires – does nothing to make the world a better place. The 5-4 Supreme Court decision known at Citizen’s United (2008) gave corporations the same free-speech rights as individuals, telling us that giving money to political causes cannot be limited in any substantial way. Meanwhile, we see the crumbling of democracies all over the world as the secular Golden Rule (those with the gold make the rules) snuffs out the spiritual one.
I do not begrudge money made through hard work; what does cause problems is when those with enough to last 1000 – or more – lifetimes do not share their success with those who made them rich. The Civil War was not just about enslavement – it was about the loss of free labor and the cost to the wealthy. Rich slave owners convinced poor white people that those whom they had enslaved were the enemy, when in reality, it was the landowners who were causing the death of the nation. When we love money more than people, we are doomed, and democracy is doomed as well. Providing a healthy way of life for your workers isn’t socialism; it is pure economic sense. And in every system throughout history, when the oppressed finally had enough, they rebelled. Moral Capitalism can alleviate the injustices of greed before that happens. James Carville, Pres. Clinton’s advisor, got it right: It’s the economy, stupid. Still is.
Prayer – Holy God, we know that work and self-sufficiency are good things. Help us to treat each other fairly so that all might be able to pursue happiness. Amen.
Today’s art is from bergensia.com.